Best Seafood Restaurants: Fresh Catch

In the Golden Isles, seafood is not just a menu item. It reflects the rhythm of the coast itself. Shrimp boats head out at sunrise, tides shape the day’s catch, and by evening, that same seafood is served just steps from the water it came from. From relaxed island staples to elevated coastal dining, here is where to find the freshest seafood on St. Simons Island and Jekyll Island.

St. Simons Island

Crabdaddy’s Seafood Grill

A true island institution, Crabdaddy’s has built its reputation on fresh seafood and bold coastal flavor. The menu leans into Southern classics like shrimp and grits, seared scallops, and daily fresh catch selections such as grouper and snapper. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming, especially in the evenings when the dining room fills with locals and visitors alike. It is the kind of place where you settle in, order a cocktail, and take your time.

Georgia Sea Grill

For a more refined take on coastal cuisine, Georgia Sea Grill delivers a polished, ingredient-driven experience. Many of the vegetables and herbs are sourced locally, and the seafood is prepared with a focus on seasonality. Dishes like seared scallops or expertly prepared fresh catch highlight simple flavors done exceptionally well. The intimate setting makes it a standout for date nights or special occasions.

Halyards

Halyards offers a modern, chef-driven approach to seafood that feels both creative and grounded in coastal tradition. Menus change regularly based on what is fresh and available, giving each visit something new. Expect thoughtful plating, layered flavors, and a quieter atmosphere that invites you to slow down and enjoy the experience.

Iguanas Seafood Restaurant

Located in the Pier Village, Iguanas is a casual favorite known for doing the basics right. Shrimp is the star here, served fried, blackened, or broiled alongside hush puppies and classic sides. The relaxed setting and outdoor seating make it an easy choice after a day at the beach. The complimentary soft serve ice cream at the end of your meal does not hurt either.

Jekyll Island

The Wharf

Set along the historic waterfront, The Wharf pairs scenic views with classic coastal dishes. Start with peel and eat shrimp or oysters, then move into a Low Country boil or fresh catch platter. As the sun sets over the water, the atmosphere shifts into something memorable with live music and coastal breezes.

Tortuga Jacks

For a beachfront dining experience, Tortuga Jacks delivers seafood with a laid back, vacation feel. As the only oceanfront tiki style restaurant on the Georgia coast, it is as much about the setting as the food. Fish tacos, shrimp plates, and cold drinks pair perfectly with ocean views and live music just steps from the sand.