Planning a trip to Georgia’s coast and deciding between St. Simons Island and Jekyll Island? While both are part of the Golden Isles and share beautiful scenery, warm Southern charm, and rich history, each offers a distinctly different experience.
This guide breaks down the key differences—beaches, activities, history, and accommodations—so you can choose the island that best fits your travel style.
Beaches: Lively Shores vs. Natural Beauty
St. Simons Island Beaches
Beaches on St. Simons Island are known for their laid-back, local feel. East Beach is one of the most popular spots, offering wide stretches of sand perfect for sunbathing, biking, and long walks. You’ll often see families, dog walkers, and visitors enjoying the easy accessibility.
While the sand here is ideal for classic beach days, some areas can be tidal, meaning the shoreline changes throughout the day.
Jekyll Island Beaches
Jekyll Island is famous for its diverse and scenic coastline. From the iconic Driftwood Beach—where weathered trees create one of the most photographed landscapes in Georgia—to quieter stretches like Great Dunes Beach Park, the beaches here feel more preserved and varied.
Jekyll’s shoreline tends to be less crowded and more visually dramatic, making it a favorite for nature lovers and photographers.
Key Difference:
St. Simons offers a more traditional, social beach experience, while Jekyll Island delivers unique, picturesque, and less crowded coastal scenery.
Activities: Classic Coastal Charm vs. Outdoor Adventure
Things to Do on St. Simons Island
St. Simons Island leans into its coastal charm with a mix of relaxation and recreation. Popular activities include:
- Biking under moss-draped oak trees
- Shopping and dining in the Pier Village area
- Visiting the historic lighthouse
- Golfing at world-class courses
- Trolley tours and fishing excursions
The pace here is relaxed but offers plenty of ways to stay entertained.
Things to Do on Jekyll Island
Jekyll Island is a hub for outdoor exploration and family-friendly attractions. Highlights include:
- Biking the island’s 20+ miles of scenic trails
- Visiting the Georgia Sea Turtle Center
- Exploring the historic district
- Kayaking through marshes and waterways
- Golfing and eco-tours
The island’s layout and design make it especially easy to explore by bike.
Key Difference:
St. Simons Island is ideal for a classic coastal getaway with shopping, dining, and golf, while Jekyll Island is perfect for outdoor adventures and active exploration.
History: Southern Heritage vs. Gilded Age Legacy
St. Simons Island History
St. Simons Island has deep historical roots dating back to Spanish exploration and colonial times. Landmarks like the St. Simons Lighthouse and Christ Church highlight its longstanding role in coastal Georgia’s history.
The island blends historical sites seamlessly into everyday life, giving it an authentic, lived-in feel.
Jekyll Island History
Jekyll Island’s history is closely tied to the exclusive Jekyll Island Club, once a retreat for America’s wealthiest families, including the Rockefellers and Morgans. Today, the Jekyll Island Historic District preserves this Gilded Age legacy with beautifully restored cottages and museums.
Key Difference:
St. Simons reflects centuries of layered Southern history, while Jekyll Island offers a unique glimpse into America’s Gilded Age and elite past.
Accommodations: Variety vs. Curated Experience
Where to Stay on St. Simons Island
St. Simons Island features a wide range of accommodations, including:
- Boutique inns
- Vacation rentals and beach homes
- Full-service resorts
- Charming bed-and-breakfasts
This variety makes it easy to find something that fits families, couples, or larger groups.
Where to Stay on Jekyll Island
Jekyll Island accommodations are more centralized and curated, with options ranging from oceanfront resorts to historic stays within the island’s district.
Because much of the island is state-managed, development is more limited, creating a quieter, more contained experience.
Key Difference:
St. Simons offers more variety and flexibility, while Jekyll Island provides a more structured, resort-style environment.
Cost & Access: What to Know Before You Go
One important distinction is access.
Jekyll Island requires a parking/entry fee for all vehicles entering the island. This fee helps support conservation efforts and maintain the island’s natural beauty.
St. Simons Island does not have an entry fee, making it more freely accessible for day trips and spontaneous visits.
Which Island Should You Choose?
Choose St. Simons Island if you’re looking for:
- A lively yet relaxed coastal town
- Easy beach access with a social atmosphere
- More dining, shopping, and nightlife options
- A wide range of accommodations
Choose Jekyll Island if you prefer:
- Scenic, less crowded beaches
- Outdoor activities and biking trails
- Family-friendly attractions and eco-experiences
- A quieter, more nature-focused setting
Experience the Best of Both
The good news? You don’t have to choose just one. St. Simons Island and Jekyll Island are only a short drive apart, making it easy to experience both during your stay in the Golden Isles.
Spend one day exploring the charm and culture of St. Simons, then head to Jekyll Island for a bike ride or sunrise at Driftwood Beach. Together, they offer a well-rounded coastal getaway that showcases the very best of Georgia’s barrier islands.
Start Planning Your Golden Isles Escape
Whether you’re drawn to the vibrant charm of St. Simons Island or the natural beauty of Jekyll Island, each destination offers something special. Understanding their differences helps you create a trip that matches your style—whether that’s relaxation, adventure, or a little of both.
Start planning your Golden Isles getaway today and discover why both islands continue to be favorites for travelers year after year.
Request a Visitor Guide
The Golden Isles Visitor Guide is your only official resource for visitor information: accommodations, activities, events, dining, shopping and much more.
